| The net energy cliff |
 |
 |
 |
| Policy - Policy |
| Sunday, 14 September 2008 07:18 |
|
Charles Hall, the father of the energy return on investment (EROI) concept, once told me that our current society would probably not be able to function if the EROI for the entire society slipped below five. What does that mean? First, a quick review. It takes energy to get energy. EROI is a measurement of how efficient a process, an enterprise or a society is in obtaining energy. EROI is usually expressed in a ratio, say, 20 to 1. That would mean that the process being studied produced 20 units of energy for every one unit expended. As it turns out, that"s about what conventional crude oil returns. Hall estimates that the United States is currently running on an EROI of just under 40 to 1. This looks like a fairly substantial margin of safety over the 5 to 1 that might lead to societal breakdown. But worrisome developments in the oil, natural gas and coal fields may send us rushing toward that figure. A post earlier this year on The Oil Drum suggests that the EROI for natural gas in North America is dropping like a stone. This is, in part, reflected in the price of natural gas which is up fourfold in this decade. It is also reflected in the number of wells and the number of total feet drilled just to maintain production. We are having to drill faster and deeper just to stay even. The recent uptick in U. S. supplies may represent a small flattening of the EROI decline, but those supplies are the product of furious drilling and huge exploration expenditures. The tar sands, presumed to be the great energy savior for North America, have long been a low EROI source of oil. Estimates range from 1 to 1 to about 7 to 1. Work by Charles Hall and his students posted on The Oil Drum gives a tentative estimate of 5.2 to 1 based on admittedly incomplete data. Coal has a very high return when used to generate electricity, around 80 to 1. But evidence now suggests that in the United States at least, not only has the energy content per ton of coal declined by more than 30 percent since 1955, but the total energy content of coal mined in the country is now falling despite rising coal tonnage. But what about nuclear? Hall and his students once again attempted to calculate the EROI. Others have made claims of 1.86 to 1 to 93 to 1. The very high estimates appear to leave out many steps in the nuclear fuel and construction cycle. Some contend that the EROI of nuclear is favorable enough--perhaps 11 to 1--to argue for expansion of nuclear power. But, if one takes into account all the energy that will be expended over time storing nuclear waste and guarding the waste and the mothballed nuclear plants in the future, the EROI could drop below 1. Essentially, we get the benefit now, and future generations get both the security and energy expenditures. On its current trajectory, nuclear power may not even maintain its share of world energy production. It would certainly be useful to know what the true EROI of nuclear power is in order to assess its importance to our energy future. Solar power has promise as shown in this chart compiled by Hall and his students. But, the estimated EROI ranges are so wide that it would be difficult to promise that solar photovoltaic could consistently provide returns above 5 to 1. This chart provides an estimate of above 70 to 1 for wind power in one location. EROI in this case, of course, depends heavily on whether the wind generators are located in ultra-windy Denmark or not-so-windy Japan. The main problem with wind and solar, however, is that they are intermittent; the energy produced is difficult to store for use during nighttime or low-wind conditions. Finally, hydroelectric has a very high EROI. While there is still room for some expansion of hydro power in the developing world, most of the good sites have already been taken in North America and Europe. And, this brings us to the idea of the net energy cliff. If our energy transition away from fossil fuels does not result in their replacement by high EROI sources of energy with the necessary versatility and storage characteristics, or if such replacements are possible, but delayed too long, then we may be facing a net energy cliff. 
|
The net energy cliff Charles Hall, the father of the energy return on investment (EROI) concept, once told me that our current society would probably not be able to function if the EROI for the entire society slipped below five.What does that mean? First,... Read more Policy | | Sunday, 14 September 2008 |
Steve Rayner: Dear Mr. President, Deal with Climate ChangeSteve Rayner, climate policy expert and lead author of The Wrong Trousers: Radically Rethinking Climate Policy (PDF), is featured in this month"s Wired Magazine. He"s on the "2008 Smart List: 15 People the Next President Should Listen To" (no matter... Read more Policy | | Wednesday, 1 October 2008 |
Time Scales and Quality of Life: How they define our FutureSince before Roe vs. Wade (1973) … the United States populace has been divided on how to treat the current/potential “quality of life” of the unborn who are not capable of expressing will of their own. For the past 20... Read more Policy | | Thursday, 22 November 2007 |
Deregulated vs. Regulated Energy PricesIn Texas in 1999, Senate Bill 7 created a deregulated electricity market within the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT). Some areas opted not to join into the fun of a deregulated market, where consumers could choose their retail electricity... Read more Policy | | TUSEDAY, 4 December 2007 |
Review: Lester Brown's Plan B 3.0: Mobilizing to Save Civilization You may want to read this book by starting with Part II. Either that or make sure all the knives are locked away so you won't slit your wrists during Part I.Lester Brown has his facts straight and uses them liberally,... Read more Policy | John | Sunday, 31 August 2008 |
Landmark study reports breakdown in biotech patent system - scientists call for overhaul of IP laws worldwide The world"s intellectual property (IP) system is broken. It"s stopping lifesaving technologies from reaching the people who need them most in developed and developing countries, according to the authors of a landmark report released in Ottawa today by an international... Read more Policy | | TUSEDAY, 9 September 2008 |
Alternative fuels taxes may be scrappedAustralianFriday 18/7/2008 Page: 4NEW taxes on alternative fuels including LPG could be delayed or scrapped by the Rudd Government under a compensation deal to balance the inflationary impact of its carbon trading scheme. In a separate measure, Treasurer Wayne Swan... Read more Policy | | Augustonday, 11 August 2008 |
Some elements of a proper energy policyA proper Energy Policy in the United States would promote (1) clarity of purpose, (2) diversification of use of energy resources, and (3) more transparent and accurate pricing of energy such that the market (consumers and energy companies) can properly... Read more Policy | John | Thursday, 22 November 2007 |
New Energy BillThe US Congress passed an energy bill yesterday and Bush signed it into law. It is both a step backward and forward for energy policy. See this CS Monitor article for a synopsis.Creating a higher CAFE standard to get to... Read more Policy | | Thursday, 20 December 2007 |
Climate protestors threaten to shut down London’s carbon marketwww.environmental-finance.comLondon, 5 February:After attracting thousands of climate protestors to the Kingsnorth power station and Heathrow airport, the Camp for Climate Action has turned its sights on leading carbon trading platform, the European Climate Exchange (ECX).The campaign group has called for... Read more Policy | | Sunday, 8 February 2009 |
The information society and its limitsThe breathtaking expansion of the Internet and the sources of information now available on it have served to conjure a cybernetic vision of unlimited growth--growth that can never be slowed for long by lack of physical resources because it is... Read more Policy | | Sunday, 8 February 2009 |
PM's carbon target plans face rethinkSummaries - Australian Financial ReviewMonday 21/7/2008 Page: 1A proposal to give parliament the task of annually setting carbon reduction targets in an emissions trading scheme (ETS) looks set to be scrapped by the Rudd Government. The proposal is part of... Read more Policy | | Thursday, 14 August 2008 |
|
More in: Policy |
|
100% - + 12Show options | |